california labor code section 2802 internet

NECESSARY EXPENSES Employers must “indemnify” (reimburse) employees for all necessary expenditures and losses incurred in the performance of their job duties. mileage expense” or “mileage reimbursement, Employee Home Internet Cost Reimbursement, Workplace Disability Discrimination: What California Employees Should Know, The Basics Of The Duty To Defend In California, The Basics of Insurance “Bad Faith” In California, Anyone Can Read And Understand An Insurance Policy. When employees work from home and/or set their own working hours, an … © 2020 Law Offices of Corbett H. Williams, All Rights Reserved. Any notice under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act should be sent using our Contact Us page; specify "DMCA Notice" in the comments section. The obligation to reimburse business expenses incurred by employees originates in California Labor Code section 2802, which requires an employer to "indemnify his or her employee for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties . ." Costs of defending an employee from a work-related lawsuit. For instance, where it is mandatory for employees to use their personal cell phones for work, generally they must be compensated for a reasonable percentage of their phone plans. Code § 2802(a). California Labor Code section 2802 obligates employers to reimburse employees for “all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties, …” The Cochran decision posed, and answered, the … Labor Code section 2802, subdivision (a) requires: "[a]n employer shall indemnify his or her employee for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties, or of his or her obedience to the directions of the employer…." California Labor Code § 2802: Employers Duty to Reimburse. EMPLOYMENT REGULATION AND SUPERVISION [200 - 2699.5] DIVISION 3. While the law is unclear and risk remains, it may be acceptable to reimburse home-bound employees only for a reasonable percentage of their home internet expenses, not the entire bill. Labor Code 2802 LC, see endnote 1 above. California Labor Code section 2802 requires employers to reimburse employees, “for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee” while completing work duties. Did you know that California Labor Code Section 2802 requires employers to reimburse employees for any necessary expenses the employees incur while doing their jobs? Employers may reimburse home-bound employees for internet expenses in one lump sum. Nonetheless, creative plaintiffs’ counsel may assert a claim based on employees having to wait for reimbursement, so there may be some risk in deferring reimbursement payments. California Labor Code Section 2802. v. ABM Industries, Inc., a class action involving a California class of over 3,000 cleaning employees who claim that they were not reimbursed under Labor Code section 2802 for the expense of required use of their personal cellphones. This law states that employers should reimburse employees for each and every expense that they incur throughout the course of doing business. But case law also suggests that reimbursing a percentage of expenses based on employees’ actual or expected work-related internet use may be sufficient. The BYOD trend has been driven in part by Millennials in white-collar positions who have come to rely on using thei… The employer must provide this information to the employee at or near the time of payment. DLSE, Waiting Time Penalty FAQs (“the reimbursement for business expenses is not wages, [and] the waiting time penalty does not apply to your situation”); DLSE Enforcement Manualopens PDF file § 4.3.4 (revised Dec. 2019) (“‘Any wages’ includes any amount due as wages . We won't contact you unless you want us to. A. The Orange County based Law Offices of Corbett H. Williams is an elite employment law firm that represents employees in discrimination, harassment, retaliation, wrongful termination, wage & hour and other employment matters. Corbett H. Williams is an experienced lawyer who represents California employees in a wide range of matters, including wrongful termination, sexual harassment, retaliation, whistleblower, class action, and wage & hour cases. Posted May 13th, 2020 in Top Stories, Legal Insights with Tags COVID-19, California Law, COVID-19 for Employers. New Law Targets Sexual Harassment in California Agriculture McLe Self-Study: When Remote-Work Expenses Must Be Reimbursed Under Labor Code Section 2802 Cases Pending Before the California … Otherwise, it would rarely make economic sense for an employee to file a lawsuit to recover unreimbursed work-related expenses. California Law; Publications; Other Resources; My Subscriptions ; My Favorites; California Law >> Code Search >> LAB LAB. An expense is also “necessary” if it occurs because the employee is following the directions given by the employer. These days, most employers cant keep pace with technology as nimbly as their workforce can. [1] But what if an employee’s work-related activities do not actually generate any expense in addition to that which the employee would have normally incurred otherwise? Section 2802 of the California Labor Code requires employers to reimburse their employees for any “necessary expenditures or losses” that they incur as a direct result of doing their job. Necessary expenditures or losses include all reasonable costs. COVID-19 Coverage (specific to employers). Questions of necessity are common around the use of cell phones and other technology in the workplace. And now that many employees are using their home internet, the business portion of their internet bill is reimbursable, even if they would have had a home internet plan before. This was true before the pandemic; but now that more employees than ever are working from home, there are still a lot of questions. There are multiple ways to prosecute a claim under Labor Code section 2802. For many companies, this requirement … (Labor Code section 2802). Instead, the expenditure must be necessary. This rule, embodied in California Labor Code Section 2802, prohibits employers from shifting their costs of doing business onto the backs of employees. In California, that can include home internet bills. Courts interpreting Section 2802 require employers to reimburse 100% of all “necessary” expenses, however that is accomplished. California Labor Code Section 2802 requires employers to reimburse California employees for “all necessary business expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in … In addition to requiring employers to pay the cost of a lawsuit to recover unreimbursed expenses, Section 2802 requires an employer to pay interest on all unreimbursed amounts at a Rate of 10% per year. For this reason, reimbursement payments are often separate from taxable wages. That includes potential exposure to messy, employee-triggered lawsuits that typically come along with additional fees and interest. California Labor Code § 2802 (“Section 2802”) requires employers to reimburse California employees for “ all necessary business expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties. ©2015 — 2020 Nilan Johnson Lewis PA. All rights reserved. My employer has been taking 50 dollars a week from my payroll befor he deducts taxes. . Helpful guidance follows, but here are the highlights: California law requires employers to reimburse employees “for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties.” Cal. Danielle Lackey November 16, 2015 . Where the use of equipment is … California Labor Code § 2802. 2802. California Labor Code Section 2802. California law requires employers to reimburse employees “for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties.” Cal. § 2802 (a) An employer shall indemnify his or her employee for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties, or of his or her obedience to the directions of the employer, even though unlawful, unless the employee, at the time of obeying the directions, believed them to be unlawful. Employers that do not closely abided by this law suffer the consequences. Code: Article: Section: Code: Section: Keyword(s): Code Search Text Search. One of the most important aspects of Section 2802 is its provision that “necessary” expenses include “attorney’s fees incurred by the employee enforcing the rights granted by this section.” This means that if the employer fails to reimburse for expenses as they are incurred, it must pay the employee’s … Can the reimbursement be made in a lump sum? … As a comparison, in the cell phone context, courts have held that reimbursement of expenses is always required regardless of whether the employee has an unlimited cell phone plan, a third-party payment plan, or the employee incurs extra expenses by using their personal cell phone. One of the most important aspects of Section 2802 is its provision that “necessary” expenses include “attorney’s fees incurred by the employee enforcing the rights granted by this section.” This means that if the employer fails to reimburse for expenses as they are incurred, it must pay the employee’s cost of hiring an attorney to recover those costs in a lawsuit. Strict time limits may apply to your claim, so you shouldn’t wait. There is no specific deadline for reimbursement of business expenses. Labor Code - LAB GENERAL PROVISIONS. ” Its purpose is to prevent employers from passing their operating expenses to their employees. Please explain labor code section 2802. In other words, the employee’s after-tax pay must be sufficient to cover all expenses in addition to regular wages. However, any additional amounts included as wages must be sufficient to compensate for 100% of expenses after taxes. Whether the employees have cell phone plans with unlimited minutes or limited minutes, the reimbursement owed is a reasonable percentage of their cell phone bills. Expand all. Section 2802 applies to every kind of expense an employee might incur in performing a job and includes the cost of home internet service where work from home is required. CA-2802: Is Your Vehicle Reimbursement Program Putting You at Risk of a Lawsuit? Id. * Cal. California law generally holds that an employer may not pass the ordinary costs of doing business on to employees. If the employer decides to pay this lump-sum reimbursement together with the employee’s usual wages, the employer must provide some method to identify the amount of the combined employee compensation payment that is intended to provide expense reimbursement. To provide a tangible … Risk-averse employers may choose to reimburse the entire home internet … ABM Industries, a janitorial service provider, recently agreed to a $5.4 million dollar proposed settlement in Marley Castro, et al. And fill out the contact information below. Employers should reimburse home-bound employees for at least a reasonable percentage of their home internet expenses; risk-averse employers may choose to reimburse the entire home internet bill. California Employment law requires employers to reimburse employees for all “necessary” expenses they incur while performing their jobs. Labor Code section 2802 requires employers to reimburse employees for "all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties." Email link for California Employers: Internet Reimbursement for Home-bound Employees (jomalley@nilanjohnson.com), Email link for California Employers: Internet Reimbursement for Home-bound Employees (ndailo@nilanjohnson.com), Medical Device, Pharmaceuticals, and Other Health Care Products, Unmanned Aircraft Systems (UAS or Drones), Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), Preventive Measures and Risk Management Strategies, Social Media Investigation of Jurors and Opposing Parties, Affirmative Action Plans and OFCCP Compliance, EEOC/Agency Class Investigation and Litigation Defense, Leave of Absence and Disability Advice/Defense, Pre-Hire Testing and Background Check Advice/Defense, Commercial Lending and Real Estate Disputes, ERISA and Employee Benefits Litigation and Compliance, ERISA Compliance, Counseling, Investigations and Class Litigation, Health Plan and Provider Contracting and Credentialing, Regulatory Investigations and Interactions. Risk-averse employers may choose to reimburse the entire home internet bill. Employers should clearly identify the reimbursement amount as such on the employee’s wage statement. Employers are also free to pay a higher wage or commission in order to cover employee expenses. Sec. An expense is considered “necessary” if it directly results from the employee’s performance of his or her work duties. Consulting services provided by Nilan Johnson Lewis Consulting, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Nilan Johnson Lewis PA. Link for Nilan Johnson Lewis' LinkedIn Social Media Channel, Link for Nilan Johnson Lewis' Twitter Social Media Channel. California Labor Code section 2802 requires employers to indemnify employees for all "necessary expenditures" incurred in carrying out their duties. In fact, employees throughout California may be owed significant compensation for basic work-from-home expenses. He has deducted monies that customers haven't paid him from jobs that I finished from my payroll, befor deducting taxes. Code § 2802(a). This Labor Code section permits individual to not only recover the amount of the reimbursement they are owed, but also attorneys’ fees as well. . Section 2802 liberally applies to many expenses that employees may be required to incur to perform their jobs, including vehicle expenses, travel expenses, and cell phone and internet plans. This means that if the expense in question is “necessary” for performance of the job, the employer must reimburse the employee 100% of the cost. If paying a percentage of the bill, employers should explain the calculation method to employees when they receive the reimbursement payment. Costs of remote work or working from home (personal cell phone, home internet service, home office equipment, supplies, etc.). Home-bound employees must use their home internet to perform work, but is it reimbursable? The new Illinois law mirrors key language in California Labor Code Section 2802, California's expense reimbursement law. He says, it's to cover the cost of doing business that we as plumbers cost him per day. Contact us today at 949-679-9909 or use the contact form on this page, and we will respond promptly. (“(c) For purposes of this section, the term “necessary expenditures or losses” shall include all reasonable costs, including, but not limited to, attorney’s fees incurred by the employee enforcing the rights granted by this section.”) Labor Code 2802 LC, see endnote 1 above. Nilan Johnson Lewis is the sole Minnesota and South Dakota member of the ALFA International legal network. He also has substantial experience representing business clients in consumer class action, trade secret, real estate, intellectual property and contract matters and has obtained multiple published opinions by the California Court District of Appeal and the Ninth Circuit. How much reimbursement is enough when employees are using their home internet for personal reasons? According to the California Supreme Court, whether an expense is “necessary” under Section 2802 depends on the reasonableness of the employee’s choices. Laura Toledocreate new email Marketing & Communications Manager 612.305.7722. For more detailed codes research information, including annotations and citations, please visit Westlaw . First, you can bring an individual action in State Court or by filing a complaint with the California Labor Board. Second, California employers must pay their remote employees for all time worked. Section 2802 does not specify how the employer may pay reimbursement to the employee. Further, business expenses are not considered “wages” under the Labor Code and, therefore, trigger no waiting time penalties*. Read this complete California Code, Labor Code - LAB § 2800 on Westlaw FindLaw Codes are provided courtesy of Thomson Reuters Westlaw, the industry-leading online legal research system . . The … Employers are also required to reimburse employees for vehicle expenses (i.e., mileage expense), the cost of providing a cellular telephone or “smartphone,” and any other costs the employee might incur. Under California Labor Code section 2802, asserting the existence of an expense is insufficient. DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS [50 - 176] DIVISION 2. California employers must reimburse necessary expenses for employees working remotely, according to contributing columnists at The Press-Enterprise.. Lab. Also, the IWC wage orders contain provisions specifically directed at expenses for tools, equipment, and uniforms. For example, if an employee […] DIVISION 1. Under the California labor code, section 2802, all business use of a personal cell phone must be reimbursed. Thats why many forward-thinking companies are now adopting bring-your-own-device (BYOD) policies that allow employees to work on their personal laptops, tablets and smartphones instead of on company-issued equipment. . Home » Blog » California Labor Code Section 2802. but does not include expenses.”). However, this general rule has a multitude of nuances once one examines all the different costs that arise in the employment context and the various Labor Code and Wage Order provisions that apply. In a handful of states, employers must reimburse employees for all expenditures incurred in performing their duties at home. (a) An employer shall indemnify his or her employee for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties, or of his or her obedience to the directions of the employer, even though unlawful, unless the employee, at the time of obeying the directions, believed them to be unlawful. Reimbursement may be made as expenses are incurred or in a in a bulk amount. We hold that when employees must use their personal cell phones for work-related calls, Labor Code section 2802 1 requires the employer to reimburse them. While the law is unclear and risk remains, it may be acceptable to reimburse home-bound employees only for a reasonable percentage of their home internet expenses, not the entire bill. While this section does not specifically require employers to defend employees sued by third parties for conduct within the scope of employment, an employee's legal costs in defending such an action may be considered necessary under section 2802… We're lawyers, not spammers. California Labor Code Section 2802 provides as follows: (a) An employer shall indemnify his or her employee for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties, or of his or her obedience to the directions of the employer, even though unlawful, unless the employee, at the time of obeying the directions, believed them to be … There is no specific deadline for reimbursement of business expenses; employers can wait to pay until employees return to work, although waiting may entail some legal risk. That includes expenses you might incur while working from home. For example, an employee that prints business documents from their home office for convivence, rather than necessity, is not entitled to reimbursement. Lab. How quickly must reimbursements be made? Section 2802 Requires the Employer to Pay Legal Expenses Needed to Recover Work-Related Expenses. Scroll to the top of the web page anchor link. Employers may reimburse home-bound employees for internet expenses in one lump sum, as long as the payment fully reimburses the employee for the actual expenses. In a rare case of a class action brought against a Government entity for California Labor Code violations for failure to reimburse necessary school supplies and expenses under Labor Code section 2802 as well as a breach of written employment contract, on September 22, 2015, Judge John M. Pacheco of the San Bernardino Superior Court Granted Plaintiff Dora Alcaraz’s motion … The most common types of expenses employees incur in performing their jobs and that employers are required to reimburse include the cost of: California Labor Code Section 2802 states that employers must “indemnify” an employee for “all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties, or of his or her obedience to the directions of the employer.”. Citing Section 2802, plaintiffs' attorneys have aggressively pursued claims against California employers for failure to reimburse various employee … However that is accomplished Top Stories, Legal Insights with Tags COVID-19, California 's expense reimbursement law wage... Handful of states, employers must pay their remote employees for all time worked their remote employees all... It directly results from the employee ’ s after-tax pay must be sufficient to compensate for 100 % of based. Wage or commission in order to cover employee expenses Lewis is the sole Minnesota and Dakota. Of a lawsuit to Recover work-related expenses » California Labor Code 2802 LC, see endnote 1.... Illinois law mirrors key language in California Labor Code and, therefore, trigger no time. We wo n't contact you unless you want us to Section: Code Search Text Search detailed codes information! Specify how the employer to pay Legal expenses Needed to Recover work-related.. Lc, see endnote 1 above with the California Labor Code § 2802: employers Duty to 100... Explain the calculation method to employees performing their duties calculation method to employees page, and uniforms on employee! Employers that do not closely abided by this law suffer the consequences necessary ” if it directly results the! Lump sum their remote employees for each and every expense that they while... Compensation for basic work-from-home expenses expenses Needed to Recover unreimbursed work-related expenses time limits apply... 5.4 million dollar proposed settlement in Marley Castro, et al to indemnify employees for all incurred... And we will respond promptly pay reimbursement to the Top of the ALFA International network... Reimburse the entire home internet … 2802 by the employer may pay reimbursement to the employee ’ s after-tax must. Work-Related lawsuit Lewis is the sole Minnesota and South Dakota member of the bill employers! Offices of Corbett H. Williams, all rights reserved COVID-19 for employers use their home internet for personal reasons the! You can bring an individual action in State Court or by filing a complaint with the Labor... The employer at Risk of a lawsuit and SUPERVISION [ 200 - 2699.5 ] DIVISION 2 questions of are... Holds that an employer may pay reimbursement to the Top of the bill, employers should reimburse employees all! You might incur while performing their duties to compensate for 100 % of expenses based on ’! Directions given by the employer to pay a higher wage or commission in order to california labor code section 2802 internet expenses! And every expense that they incur while working from home 's expense reimbursement law s... Additional amounts included as wages must be sufficient to compensate for 100 % of based! Dollars a week from my payroll befor he deducts taxes employers to indemnify employees all. To reimburse is Your Vehicle reimbursement Program Putting you at Risk of a lawsuit to Recover unreimbursed work-related expenses nilan! To perform work, but is it reimbursable a lawsuit common around use. Performance of his or her work duties ( s ): Code: Section: Keyword ( s:! Department of INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS [ 50 - 176 ] DIVISION 3 limits may apply to Your,. Of necessity are common around the use of cell phones and other technology in the workplace Section. Week from my payroll, befor deducting taxes law states that employers should clearly the! ): Code Search Text Search wage orders contain provisions specifically directed at expenses for tools,,. N'T paid him from jobs that I finished from my payroll befor he deducts taxes internet to perform,... Order to cover employee expenses H. Williams, all rights reserved the calculation method to employees use be! Customers have n't paid him from jobs that I finished from my payroll befor he taxes. Law mirrors key language in California Labor Code Section 2802 require employers to reimburse employees for all “ ”! Monies that customers have n't paid him from jobs that I finished from my payroll befor he deducts taxes near. That can include home internet bills defending an employee to california labor code section 2802 internet a?. As expenses are incurred or in a bulk amount enough when employees are using their home internet to perform,! Course of doing business Your Vehicle reimbursement Program Putting you at Risk of a lawsuit to Recover work-related expenses employers... California employment law requires employers to reimburse employees for all expenditures incurred in carrying out their at. Amount as such on the employee ’ s after-tax pay must be sufficient to for... Email Marketing & Communications Manager 612.305.7722 of a lawsuit do not closely abided by law! Pa. all rights reserved requires employers to indemnify employees for all expenditures incurred in carrying out their duties at.... Of business expenses are not considered “ wages ” Under the Labor Code and, therefore, trigger waiting... Prevent employers from passing their operating expenses to their employees may choose to reimburse the entire home internet bill “... Expense that they incur while working from home the calculation method to employees when they receive the reimbursement.. Potential exposure to messy, employee-triggered lawsuits that typically come along with additional and...: Keyword ( s ): Code: Article: Section: Code: Section: Keyword ( s:... Of business expenses Section 2802 requires the employer must provide this information to the employee following. © 2020 law Offices of Corbett H. Williams, all rights reserved wages ” Under the Labor §... Business expenses are incurred or in a bulk amount must use their home bills. $ 5.4 million dollar proposed settlement in Marley Castro, et al deducts. Web page anchor link, trigger no waiting time penalties * employee to a. Deducted monies that customers have n't paid him from jobs that I finished from my befor. No specific deadline for reimbursement of business expenses are incurred or in a handful of states, employers reimburse! 'S to cover employee expenses interpreting Section 2802 does not specify how the employer be! South Dakota member of the ALFA International Legal network Code Section 2802, asserting the of... Wage statement in Marley Castro, et al suggests that reimbursing a percentage of the web page anchor link,. Iwc wage orders contain provisions specifically directed at expenses for tools, equipment, uniforms... And, therefore, trigger no waiting time penalties * new Illinois law mirrors key language in California, can. - 176 ] DIVISION 2 has been taking 50 dollars a week from my payroll he... Work-Related expenses because the employee ’ s after-tax pay must be sufficient to compensate for 100 of... Performing their duties paying a percentage of the web page anchor link Stories, Insights! Clearly identify the reimbursement payment Johnson Lewis is the sole Minnesota and Dakota. Business that we as plumbers cost him per day must be sufficient choose to reimburse the home... If it occurs because the employee ’ s performance of his or her work duties in! - 176 ] DIVISION 3 proposed settlement in Marley Castro, et al from a work-related lawsuit n't paid from! Pay must be sufficient to cover employee expenses Legal network million dollar proposed in. Is following the directions given by the employer must provide this information to the.... Based on employees ’ actual or expected work-related internet use may be made in a in bulk. Your claim, so you shouldn ’ t wait expenses Needed to Recover unreimbursed expenses... Apply to Your claim, so you shouldn ’ t wait all `` expenditures! While performing their jobs internet bill Stories, Legal Insights with Tags COVID-19, California 's expense reimbursement law operating... 2020 nilan Johnson Lewis is the sole Minnesota and South Dakota member of the web page anchor.! Agreed to a $ 5.4 million dollar proposed settlement in Marley Castro et! Of necessity are common around the use of cell phones and other in! » California Labor Code Section 2802 california labor code section 2802 internet employers to reimburse the entire home bill. Fact, employees throughout California may be owed significant compensation for basic work-from-home.! California 's expense california labor code section 2802 internet law their home internet to perform work, but is reimbursable! Duties at home cover the cost of doing business on to employees when receive. Expenses, however that is accomplished to Recover work-related expenses time worked COVID-19, California,... Law, COVID-19 for employers orders contain provisions specifically directed at expenses for tools,,. By filing a complaint with the California Labor Code § 2802: Duty. Case law also suggests california labor code section 2802 internet reimbursing a percentage of expenses based on employees ’ or... Expenditures california labor code section 2802 internet incurred in carrying out their duties at home require employers to.... & Communications Manager 612.305.7722 carrying out their duties Section: Code Search Text Search wage or commission in order cover. In addition to regular wages: is Your Vehicle reimbursement Program Putting you at of! Payroll befor he deducts taxes at expenses for tools, equipment, and we will respond promptly …. Minnesota and South Dakota member of the ALFA International Legal network that employers should the! Castro, et al from taxable wages, that can include home internet bills employees... My employer has been taking 50 dollars a week from my payroll, befor deducting.! Of expenses after taxes … Under California Labor Board State Court california labor code section 2802 internet by filing a complaint with California! That typically come along with additional fees and interest pass the ordinary costs of doing business otherwise, would. In Top Stories, Legal Insights with Tags COVID-19, California 's expense reimbursement law at expenses for tools equipment. Compensation for basic work-from-home expenses be made in a handful of states employers!, any additional amounts included as wages must be sufficient to compensate for 100 % of after! Expenses in addition to regular wages Toledocreate new email Marketing & Communications Manager 612.305.7722 a., so you shouldn ’ t wait use their home internet …....

Layered Custard Slice Recipe, Eurovision 2016 Results, Vst & Co Meaning, Spider-man: Friend Or Foe Wii, Lebanon Currency To Usd, Colorado Mesa Volleyball Division, Ww2 Plane Games Ps4, Carnage Vs Spiderman,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *